Question.3739 - Do you believe that importation or deprivation plays a larger role in the differences in the subculture between women and men in prison?
Answer Below:
Do you believe that importation or deprivation plays a larger role in the differences in the subculture between women and men in prison? The differences in the subculture between women and men in prison can be significantly influenced by both importation and deprivation theories, but many argue that importation plays a larger role. Importation theory suggests that inmates bring their backgrounds, experiences, and social identities into the prison environment. A history of trauma, victimization, and a strong emphasis on relationships are often included for women. In prison, women often form close-knit bonds and support networks, which is quite the opposite among male inmates as they have an aggressive dynamic following a hierarchical relationship. A subculture can be formed whose main focus is on relations on the basis of emotional connections over competition (Haggerty & Bucerius, 2020). On the other hand, deprivation theory posits that the prison environment itself shapes inmate behavior due to the loss of freedom, autonomy, and social status. While deprivation certainly affects both genders, the unique experiences of womensuch as motherhood and societal expectationscan amplify the impact of importation. Women often face challenges related to their roles as caregivers, which influence their interactions and coping strategies within the prison system (Haggerty & Bucerius, 2020). In conclusion, while both theories are relevant, importation arguably plays a more significant role in shaping the distinct subcultures of male and female inmates. The personal histories and social dynamics that women bring into prison create a unique environment that differs fundamentally from that of their male counterparts. Reference: Haggerty, K. D., & Bucerius, S. (2020). The proliferating pains of imprisonment. Incarceration, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/2632666320936432More Articles From Others
.ico)
.ico)
.ico)
.ico)
