Question.1212 - Looking at the same documentary, please look at the second section about the twins and medical malpractice. Please analyze that case and tell me if you agree or disagree with the conclusion of the jury. What are your thoughts about caps on medical malpractice claims? Please be detailed and remember that you need an OP and at least 2 responses to the others.
Answer Below:
According to the evidence presented jury that McDonald's had a history of serving excessively hot coffee, resulting in numerous burn cases, the decision to hold McDonald's accountable for negligence seems justified from the reasoning - due to her old age with fragile skin, the temperature of the coffee despite age it is hot to human skin, McDonald's apparent indifference to previous incidents and failure to address the issue warranted legal intervention; with this Stella Liebeck's injuries were substantial, justifying the compensation awarded. While caps on medical malpractice claims are designed to prevent excessive compensation, they may not always be fair. In some cases, the severity of the harm caused may exceed the set limits, leaving victims inadequately compensated but striking a balance between preventing frivolous lawsuits and ensuring fair compensation for legitimate cases is crucial. Blanket caps may hinder justice in cases where the damages are exceptionally severe or when negligence is egregious. This case became a symbol of frivolous lawsuits in the media, influencing public perception negatively and it was used as a rallying point for tort reform. The push for tort reform, including caps on damages, gained momentum, fueled by misconceptions about the Liebeck case. It highlights the impact of public perception on legal changes. The civil justice system provides individuals with the means to hold wrongdoers accountable, ensuring a level playing field where individuals can confront powerful entities, emphasizing the importance of maintaining access to courts. References Hot Coffee. (2011). Tubi | Hot Coffee. Retrieved January 24, 2024, from https://tubitv.com/movies/310498/hot-coffee. Center for Justice & Democracy, New York City. (n.d.). McDonalds Hot Coffee Case - Read the Facts NOT the Fiction. McDonalds Coffee Case Facts. https://www.ttla.com/?pg=McDonaldsCoffeeCaseFacts#:~:text=The%20jury%20awarded%20Liebeck%20%24200%2C000,of%20%241.3%20million%20a%20day.)More Articles From Medicine
.ico)
.ico)
.ico)
.ico)
